Table of Contents

    Volnay or Pommard: how to choose between two great red Burgundy wines

    Introduction

    Burgundy abounds in prestigious appellations, and some stand out for their very distinct characters despite being geographically close. This is the case with Volnay and Pommard, two emblematic villages of the Côte de Beaune, whose red wines made from Pinot Noir offer very different profiles. So how do you choose between a Volnay that is all finesse and a more firmly structured Pommard? Here is a simple, practical guide to help you make your choice according to your tastes, your dishes or what you feel like at the moment.

    One terroir, two expressions: the impact of geology

    Pommard: the imprint of iron-rich clays

    The Pommard vineyard sits on heavy clay-limestone soils, very rich in red (iron-rich) clay, which encourages:

    • A slow, steady water supply
    • Deep rooting of the vines
    • A denser tannic structure in the wine

    Pommard wines are therefore generally more muscular, full-bodied and firmly structured, with good ageing potential.

    Volnay: the lightness of marly limestone

    In Volnay, the slopes are steeper and the soils drain better, with a predominance of limestone marls and limestone scree. This composition encourages:

    • Vines that struggle more, but produce concentrated grapes
    • Great aromatic finesse
    • Wines that are finer, suppler and more elegant

    The same grape, a different style

    Both AOCs produce only red wines made from Pinot Noir. However:

    • Volnay: freshness, lightness, floral notes (violet, peony), crunchy red fruit.
    • Pommard: power, concentration, aromas of black cherry, leather, forest floor.

    Volnay: delicacy and lace in a bottle

    Volnay charms with its finesse and floral bouquet. Here you will find:

    • Aromas of violet, cherry and raspberry.
    • A supple, silky palate with smooth, well-integrated tannins.
    • An airy, subtle style that is approachable young.

    Recommended if you like fine, elegant wines, perfect with poultry, pork tenderloin or refined vegetarian cooking.

    See our selection of Volnay, including the Volnay Premier Cru Santenots 2022 from Maison Edouard Delaunay.

    Pommard: structure, depth and intensity

    Pommard is one of the most powerful reds of the Côte de Beaune. It offers:

    • Intense aromas of blackberry, blackcurrant, leather and spices.
    • A dense, tannic, firmly structured palate.
    • Great ageing potential.

    The one to choose if you love wines for ageing, or to accompany more robust dishes: red meats, daube, game.

    Explore our available Pommard, including the Pommard 1er Cru Les Épenots 2021 from Domaine Dubreuil-Fontaine.

    Which food and wine pairings?

    Dishes Volnay Pommard
    Roast poultry Ideal Excellent
    Pork tenderloin with a light sauce Perfect Less suitable
    Boeuf bourguignon Less suitable Very good match
    Aged goat's cheese Very good match Less suitable
    Game (venison, wild boar) Too delicate Perfect

    Key points

    • Volnay: finesse, suppleness, floral aromas, immediate pleasure.
    • Pommard: structure, power, deep aromas, ageing potential.
    • Two expressions of Pinot Noir to explore as the mood takes you.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the main difference between Volnay and Pommard?

    Both Côte de Beaune appellations produce only Pinot Noir, but on very different soils. Pommard sits on heavy, iron-rich clays that encourage powerful, dense and tannic wines. Volnay relies on better-draining limestone marls, giving fine, silky and floral wines. In short: Pommard is power, Volnay is elegance.

    Which wine should you choose between Volnay and Pommard to go with boeuf bourguignon?

    Pommard is the natural choice for this type of dish: its tannic structure and its aromas of black fruit, leather and spices are a perfect match for the richness of the red wine sauce. A Volnay, finer and more floral, risks being overwhelmed by the intense flavours of the dish. For the best pairing with boeuf bourguignon, choose a Pommard aged 5 to 10 years, lightly decanted.

    How long should you keep a Volnay or a Pommard in the cellar?

    A village Volnay can be enjoyed from 5 to 12 years; the Premiers Crus (Clos des Chênes, Champans) will keep for up to 15 to 20 years in great vintages. A Pommard generally calls for more patience: allow 8 to 15 years for a Village and 12 to 25 years for a Premier Cru such as Les Épenots or Les Rugiens.

    How much does a good Volnay or Pommard cost?

    A Volnay or Pommard Village costs between €30 and €60 depending on the estate and the vintage. The Premiers Crus generally start at around €50 to €80 and can exceed €150 from the most renowned producers. Both appellations offer a very good balance between prestige and affordability compared with the Grands Crus of the Côte de Nuits.

    Can Volnay and Pommard be served at the same temperature?

    Broadly speaking, yes: around 15 to 17 °C. For a young, tight Pommard, a slightly higher temperature (17 °C) helps to open up the dense tannins. A mature Volnay benefits from being served a little cooler (15 °C) to preserve its floral finesse. In both cases, decanting for 20 to 30 minutes is recommended for vintages less than 8 years old.

    Are there any must-try Premiers Crus in Volnay and Pommard?

    In Volnay, the most renowned Premiers Crus are Clos des Chênes, Champans and Taillepieds for their depth, and Caillerets for their elegance. In Pommard, Les Rugiens (especially the Bas) and Les Épenots are considered the most characteristic expressions of the appellation, with a power and complexity approaching Grand Cru level.

    Recommended external sources